Knight Foundation

Informed & Engaged Communities

Knight Blog

The blog of the John S. & James L. Knight Foundation

News Challenge on Networks wants your likes and reblogs

March 21, 2012, 11:52 a.m., Posted by John Bracken – 2 Comments

likesandreblogs

We announced last week that the five News Challenge applications that receive the most support from the public will advance to the second round of consideration along with the  100 or so projects identified by our review process.  Some applicants have expressed confusion by what we meant by public support, so I wanted to clarify our plans.

First, as I mentioned in the previous post, we’ll be selecting those five based on the total number of likes and reblogs on Tumblr. In addition, in our evaluation of the proposals, we will take into account the conversations taking place on the Tumblr comments page and on Twitter. Tracking more than that is difficult for us. However, if you feel like there are other conversations happening on other networks, please mention and link to them in the comments of your application page - we’ll take them into consideration too.

We’ll stop counting the Tumblr likes and reblogs on midnight, March 29. We’ll continue to follow the online conversations throughout our evaluation period in April.

I hope that helps -  as ever, please hit us up if you’ve any additional questions.

By John Bracken, director/Journalism and Media Innovation at Knight Foundation

Choose how to get news and tips about applying for the Knight News Challenge:

Follow #newschallenge on Twitter or sign up for News Challenge alerts
        

•   Follow us on Twitter #newschallenge

•   Like us on Facebook

•   Join us on Google+

 

 

Comments

March 22, 2012, 2:53 p.m.

Tom Foremski

It seems strange that the winners of the grants will be the ones best able to mobilize support from friends and families rather than on the merits of their proposals as judged by experts. Crowd sourcing has its place but seems misplaced in this instance. Especially with the focus on Tumblr. That community is not known for a strong news focus.

March 22, 2012, 4:07 p.m.

Knight Foundation

Tom - Tumblr hearts and reblogs account for only 5 out of approximately 100 finalists (and they are not guaranteed to be winners by any means). Hearts and reblogs aren't the only criteria for moving applications to the next round. Each newschallenge entry is read at least twice by the expert panel of judges.

Andrew - If you're having issues with the likes and reblogs, that's a Tumblr issue and you can reach out to their customer service directly.

Add Your Comment