Knight Foundation

Informed & Engaged Communities

Knight Blog

The blog of the John S. & James L. Knight Foundation

News Challenge on open gov launches Feb. 12

Jan. 30, 2013, 11:50 a.m., Posted by John Bracken – 19 Comments

Photo credit: Flickr user Ed Schipul

The Knight News Challenge on open government will run from Feb. 12 to March 18. It’s an opportunity to win part of the $5 million we’ll use this year to support innovative projects.

We expect the News Challenge to generate proposals to improve the way citizens and governments interact. Projects could help parents evaluate schools, make weather data more usable, identify best routes from one town to another, or identify pork in the federal budget.

Just as we do with “news,” we’re defining “open government” broadly. Wikipedia says it “holds that citizens have the right to access the documents and proceedings of the government to allow for effective public oversight.” The OpenGov Foundation says it’s about “making it easier for people to access and use as much government information as possible.” In their book Open Government, Daniel Lathrop and Laurel Ruma describe it even more broadly as “transparency, collaboration and participation.”

One of our goals for the News Challenge is to involve more people in the use of technology to solve community problems. “Dozens of developers looking at each other in conference rooms over pizza is never going to lead to making lives better... without the active involvement of real residents expressing real needs and advocating for software that makes sense to them,” wrote Daniel O’Neil of the Smart Chicago Collaborative recently. We hope to help extend the spirit of open gov beyond those conference rooms, and to catalyze partnerships between hackers, civic innovators, governments, journalists and others. As a social investor, we feel the time is right to help advance the field.

We are looking for more than just applicants for this challenge; we’re looking for participants. The challenge will open on Feb. 12 with an “inspiration” phase where anyone - journalists, state and local officials, citizens, community foundations, schools, others - can share problems they’d like to see solved and success stories they’d like to see accelerated. We hope they’ll continue to participate with their comments as applicants start submitting project entries on Feb. 19. We’ll announce the winners in June.

With this News Challenge, we’re building on a number of existing and past Knight Foundation investments in the field — leaders like Sunlight Foundation, Code for America, Open Knowledge Foundation; information and data projects like TurboVote, EveryBlock, The State Decoded, Poderopedia; and projects working to make it easier for citizens to engage with government, like Recovers.org, Textizen and Local Data. And projects built on open data are among the most popular at leading news organizations like the Texas Tribune and ProPublica.

Catherine Bracy (who worked with us on the News Challenge in 2011) recently described why she’s decided to work on open gov at Code for America:

“...government is us. We get out of it what we put in and, as citizens, we don’t have the luxury of being able to write government off. The only way for us to make it better is to engage with it. Technologists have so much potential to fix what’s broken about democracy and it’s vitally important that we do.”

We’ll have more details when we launch on Feb. 12 and will also hold open office hours at 1:00 p.m. ET on Thursday, Feb. 7. Stay tuned to @knightfdn and #newschallenge for more details.

In the meantime, if you have any questions, leave them here in the comment field, or hit me up at bracken@knightfoundation.org.

By John Bracken, director/journalism and media innovation at Knight Foundation.

Note: This blog post has been edited to spell Daniel Lothrop's name correctly.

Comments

Jan. 30, 2013, 3:25 p.m.

Jay

"Daniel" Lathrop

Jan. 31, 2013, 11:55 p.m.

Jen Padgett

We LOVE this challenge! Cannot wait for it to open. We hope our app that teaches folks how to advocate for themselves with their local representation will be a hit!

Feb. 1, 2013, 2:52 p.m.

Emale

I'm looking forward to this one!

Feb. 1, 2013, 3:17 p.m.

Pedro Prieto-Martín

OpenGov Standards is trying to get definitions and concepts that go beyond that confusing "transparency, participation and collaboration".

They propose, instead, to consider these three elements: Transparency, Participation and Accountability.
http://www.opengovstandards.org/?page_id=60
It is worth checking.

Feb. 1, 2013, 4:02 p.m.

M Mehlmann

Great initiative! Is it only open to applicants in the USA?

Feb. 2, 2013, 3:32 p.m.

Anna Haynes

Adobe could and should be part of the solution here; I just sent this [grammatically questionable] email to their spokeswoman:

What is Adobe doing to aid government "data liberation"?

Your company is a stakeholder and could offer solutions, so please be part of the "Open
government/open data" conversation. (Knight Foundation link below)

We in the U.S. have a structural problem with government transparency that's exacerbated by
Adobe, but that Adobe could act to solve. Perhaps this is already happening (if so could you
please point me to an online writeup?)

When government agencies do publish data, it's often inside a PDF, where it's often not
extractable by mortals without substantial (and in principle unneeded) effort or tool
expenditures; this is unnecessarily obstructionist and needs to change, as the Knight
Foundation (whose current "Open Government" Challenge involves freeing and using
government data) and Code for America, among other prgs, are now pushing for.

For PDF creation, does Adobe offer as standard a "publish the data alongside the PDF, in an
importable format" option, that's turned on by default?

If not, how is Adobe helping to make it as easy as possible for governments to free their data
yet still publish their documents as PDFs?

Please be part of the conversation & the solution. See:
http://www.knightfoundation.org/blogs/knightblog/2013/1/30/news-challenge-open-gov-launches-feb-12/

--------------
(FYI, your post (including invitation to comment) was also posted on the tumblr blog which has no comments. Maybe tumblr blog should just link to here?)

Feb. 2, 2013, 4:24 p.m.

Elizabeth

Hi M Mehlmann, thanks for your question. The News Challenge is open to anyone, anywhere. You don't need to be based in the U.S. to apply.

Feb. 2, 2013, 10:14 p.m.

sayani

Hi,
I am Agrijournalist working the farmer issues and my personal research tells me in INDIA the farmers are still
not involved in the price determining factors and are exploited by the middlemen, Agrimarkets and most important by the INDIAN GOVERNMENT.
If we could device a system which is operated and monitored by the farmers themselves then for sure there will be no suicide deaths, no subsidy scams, exploitation by middlemen and corporate companies.
Mobile would be the best device to go with and as already one of the the knight fellow : SHUBHRANSHU CHOUDHARY fouder of CGNETSWARA with whom i associated has created a good platform for this purpose, i feel some more ADD ONS to be done and execute this. thnaks

Feb. 8, 2013, 2:05 p.m.

Anna

Adobe's response to objections about data in PDFs not being machine-readable is in here:
https://blogs.adobe.com/insidepdf/2011/10/my-pdf-hammer-revision.html

(My reading: yes the data can be published in machine-readable form within a PDF "envelope", but it's not the default and it's not well known (and I don't know how intuitive the process is.))

Feb. 12, 2013, 6:57 a.m.

Susan

I lived in a FL community for 16 years where many branches of local government constantly and deliberately violated FL Sunshine Open Records Laws. There was only one newspaper in the town, owned by Scripps, and the newspaper itself also failed to report or disclose violations of Open Government laws known to it. I filed one lawsuit about Sunshine Law Open Records violations but the court clerk was so corrupt that my lawsuit went into a black hole. I eventually left the town and hope never to return. But here is what would have helped me and others in that community:

(1) A public interest law firm that is willing to file Sunshine Law lawsuits at no cost for individuals who stumble upon corruption in government. To say it is difficult for the average citizen to find lawyers interested in filing Sunshine Lawsuits, and to be able to afford these legal services, is an understatement. When the violations of open govt laws are political in nature and deliberate -- and lawyers are just as interested in protecting corrupt politicians as the local newspaper -- the community of honest and outraged citizens don't stand a chance.

(2) A highly publicized and annual contest from statewide chapters of news editors where the WORST JOURNALISM is recognized along with the best. Even though I left this FLorida community, what happened was so egregious it still haunts me. I have recently written to the Fl Society of News Editors trying to convince them to add a "Dark Cloud" Award for WORST JOURNALISM - media that deliberately conceals SUnshine Law violations. So far I have not received a response from them. News editors like to award "the best" in journalism, but we really need to highlight the WORST in journalism, too, meaning: when corporate-owned media is destroying the People's right to know as a favor to political pals.

(3) We need a national data base run by a foundation so that when a lawsuit is filed on Sunshine Law violations as my lawsuit, the individual citizen can immediately report to the online data base that a lawsuit has been filed -- and let the date base people go and attempt to immediately obtain a certified copy of that lawsuit from the courthouse, as well as other documents from the courthouse. I tried twice to obtain certified documents from the courthouse files, and twice I was told by court clerks -- who should have printed out the court file from their computer and certified it - the following lie: "YOu can't have a copy of your court file now because it's with the judge." There is long list of allegedly existing documents in this allegedly existing court file online at the county court site, but -- I have never seen these court documents or been able to obtain such. I would like someone else to now try.

Thank you for considering my suggestions.

Feb. 12, 2013, 7:24 a.m.

Susan

Continued from above

Another suggestion is this:

(4) The American Society of News Editors (ASNE) and
the state chapters (such as in Florida, the Florida Society of News Editors, FSNE) should revoke the memberships of members who deliberately and persistently conceal Open Government violations by corrupt public officials.

And such revoking of membership should be highly publicized.

I am going to write to ASNE and ask them to revoke the membership of the editor of the Scripps-owned Florida newspaper that deliberately concealed a Sunshine Public Records violation of a public official -- and continue to conceal this violation for five years 2007-2012 (and continuing to the present), even though: that public official, a public schools superintendent, LOST HIS JOB over this Sunshine Public Records violation which was publicly cited by the chair of the school board.

None of this Sunshine Law Public Records violation has ever been reported by the local newspaper, which constantly publishes outright fabrication and lies to its readers.

I wish I could saw I was making this up, but I am not. Since journalists have no professional licenses to lose, I think the professional organizations of news editors (and the editor of that FL newspaper is a member of both ASNE and FSNE) need to be willing to oust news editor members who are just posing as "journalists" when it can be proved the member is persistently and deliberately concealing Sunshine Law violations know to the editor and newspaper.

Feb. 12, 2013, 7:25 a.m.

Susan

I meant to type: I wish I could "say" I was making this up...

Feb. 12, 2013, 9:37 a.m.

Susan

I will post on this site the letter I send to ASNE.
In addition, here are two other thoughts I have about what problems in bringing more Sunshine Violations to come to light:

1) I contacted several prominent lawyers whose reason for not helping me was this: "It's a conflict of interest" for them, because: they represent media companies. Thus, representing individual citizens in pro bono cases for Sunshine Violations was not high on their list at all.

2) The local ACLU chapter of the Florida town where I lived eventually filed a different Sunshine violation lawsuit, but, I honestly think: when ACLU chapters are run by a small number of people, and there is a lot of corruption in law enforcement in a town, the ACLU lawyer may be intimidated from filing Sunshine lawsuits; just my own personal opinion. These corrupt law enforcement officers can pull over anyone on the road and arrest the person for anything. It is an extremely situation when you realize you live in an area where there is literally no Rule of Law and no access to the courts for honest individuals. It's like a banana republic.

That is why I think more efforts on the state and national level need to be made, in recognition of just how much corruption can exist when a town has only one political party in power and only one newspaper. It is really scarey and frightening when you start recognizing just how much abuse of power exists and can exist to harm you in retaliation for trying to do the right thing.

I also personally believe a newspaper that fabricates news stories for five years to conceal a Sunshine public records violation of a public official should lose their business license from the state to do business as a "newspaper." If they want to call themselves a daily ruse, or a daily gossip newsletter, that is fine; but they are not a daily "news"paper.

Feb. 12, 2013, 9:41 a.m.

Susan

I will post on this site the letter I send to ASNE.
In addition, here are two other thoughts I have about what problems in bringing more Sunshine Violations to come to light:

1) I contacted several prominent lawyers whose reason for not helping me was this: "It's a conflict of interest" for them, because: they represent media companies. Thus, representing individual citizens in pro bono cases for Sunshine Violations was not high on their list at all.

2) The local ACLU chapter of the Florida town where I lived eventually filed a different Sunshine violation lawsuit, but, I honestly think: when ACLU chapters are run by a small number of people, and there is a lot of corruption in law enforcement in a town, the ACLU lawyer may be intimidated from filing Sunshine lawsuits; just my own personal opinion. These corrupt law enforcement officers can pull over anyone on the road and arrest the person for anything. It is an extremely scarey situation when you realize you live in an area where there is literally no Rule of Law and no access to the courts for honest individuals. It's like a banana republic.

That is why I think more efforts on the state and national level need to be made, in recognition of just how much corruption can exist when a town has only one political party in power and only one newspaper. It is really scarey and frightening when you start recognizing just how much abuse of power exists and can exist to harm you in retaliation for trying to do the right thing.

I also personally believe a newspaper that fabricates news stories for five years to conceal a Sunshine public records violation of a public official should lose their business license from the state to do business as a "newspaper." If they want to call themselves a daily ruse, or a daily gossip newsletter, that is fine; but they are not a daily "news"paper.

Feb. 12, 2013, 3 p.m.

craig o'donnell

For Anna:

Some thoughts on Adobe.

...I believe Scribd tries to use OCR on scanned PDFs that are uploaded there so the context is indexed by search engines.

...Each state needs a Transpawiki where materials are routinely uploaded by all partiesconcerned with transparency. In my experience there's way too much focus on the Federal Gov't and not enough on the state level.

...I often get "electronic format" documents as scanned PDF files. Here's my workaround:

- feed them through an office quality printer-scanner set to "Text" and 600 dpi.
- take the resulting file and open it with Adobe Acrobat
- tell it to do OCR
- tell it to optimize the file for compatibility with Acro 9.x

This is tedious but it works fairly well. It is only a workaround.

...I routinely get "searchable PDFs" from certain govt agencies. If the originals are created in Word (which seems likely 100 percent of the time, minus a meaningless fraction) there should be a plug-in or add-on which is a "Make PDF" option.

...Apple OS X machines offer a print option to create a PDF.

So it seems to be a social engineering and not a software engineering issue.

Feb. 13, 2013, 11:55 a.m.

Jean Lotus

I would like to see an app that links corporate and trust board membership and ownership to specific government grants and also to campaign contributions. All of this is online, but it just needs to be able to talk to each other.

March 13, 2013, 11:55 a.m.

Jay Lee

If no objection is filed/Defeat all courts/demand the Damages US Supreme court forms/www.topix.com
I believe that –Award-winning Social Justice are had been truly engaged!!!Moreover long March toward.
I’m Immigration from South Korea in 1994, founder of Orange County Taxicab Worker s Corp.first time our country History all most 41 nation join tighter Sponsored Local needy children Home Boys basketball Team to HOOP IT UP SEA WORLD ORLANDO, FL Also Year 2008 form the Jay Lee Family Hope Foundation (Corp.) WV USA seed been plan But run out Resource …as you may know “Fundraising Grandchild Return home Challenge NOW!” Also Pending U.S. Supreme Court case #10-9061 Pro Se filed, I Truly believe that I’m an participate Citizens civic duty. This is Simple but profound Principle-golden rule believing AmericanDream,Freedom,Liberty,Equality,Justices for Democracy Also The Idea of Open government are bottomless gold mine for democracy Spirits but we must know the deeper we dig, the more riches we discover. “Hope for Promised Land” also Equal care to all people, regardless of their color or country our land, that should be our goal, It’s like a road map for democracy voice of Spirits and hopes of one city to next village, and next state ,Around the World we put the golden rule into action. Rule of Law when we believe that comes wisdom of democracy. It’s like a road map for Democracy. Knight News Challenge winners receive a share of $5 million in funding Notice; please you see this messages send to your friend Thanks 3/13/2013 Jay Lee

March 14, 2013, 6:37 a.m.

Councilwoman Gerrie Schipske

I am grappling on how to reach my growing population of seniors who do not use the internet and when asked say they get their information about the city on television. We do not have a local station but most homes are connected with verizon fios or charter cable.

Add Your Comment